Skip to content

Nginx vs. Caddy vs. Traefik for Hop3

For the Hop3 use case—a PaaS-like system that needs to programmatically manage routes for various applications—the key feature is dynamic configuration. Here’s a comparison of the three major reverse proxies based on this requirement.

1. Nginx

  • Overview: The industry standard for high-performance web serving and reverse proxying. It’s known for its stability, efficiency, and extensive feature set.
  • Configuration Methods:
    • Static Files (Primary): The traditional and most common method. You write configuration blocks in .conf files, typically in /etc/nginx/sites-available/, and link them into /etc/nginx/sites-enabled/.
    • Applying Changes: After modifying a .conf file, you must signal the Nginx process to reload its configuration using nginx -s reload. This is a graceful reload that doesn’t drop connections.
    • Dynamic API:
      • Open Source: The open-source version of Nginx does not have a built-in REST API for dynamically adding/removing server blocks or routes. The typical “dynamic” workflow is to have a control plane (like your Python code) that:
        1. Generates a .conf file from a template.
        2. Places it in the Nginx configuration directory.
        3. Executes nginx -s reload via a shell command.
      • Nginx Plus (Commercial): The paid version includes a robust REST API for on-the-fly reconfiguration without reloads.

2. Caddy

  • Overview: A modern, security-focused reverse proxy written in Go. Its flagship feature is automatic HTTPS by default. It’s designed for simplicity and ease of use.
  • Configuration Methods:
    • Caddyfile: A simple, high-level configuration file that is very easy to read and write. Caddy automatically provisions and renews SSL certificates for any site defined in the Caddyfile.
    • JSON API (Primary for Dynamic Use): This is Caddy’s superpower for your use case. Caddy exposes a full-featured REST API on localhost:2019 by default. You can GET, POST, PATCH, and DELETE any part of the configuration tree as a JSON object. The changes are applied instantly and atomically without a process reload. Your refactored code is a perfect example of using this API.
    • JSON Config File: You can also provide the entire configuration as a single JSON file at startup.

3. Traefik

  • Overview: A cloud-native edge router/reverse proxy, also written in Go. It was built specifically for dynamic, container-based environments like Docker and Kubernetes.
  • Configuration Methods:
    • Static Configuration (TOML/YAML): Used to configure entrypoints (e.g., ports :80, :443) and providers at startup.
    • Dynamic Configuration (Providers): This is Traefik’s core concept. Traefik discovers services automatically by watching “providers.”
      • Service Discovery Providers: It can watch the Docker socket, Kubernetes API, etc., and automatically create routes for new containers/services that are launched with specific labels.
      • File Provider: It can watch a directory for YAML/TOML files that define routes. When you add or change a file, Traefik reconfigures itself automatically. This is a common way to integrate with systems that can drop config files.
      • REST API: Traefik also has a REST API for dynamic configuration, similar to Caddy, although its primary design philosophy favors the provider model.

Summary Table & Recommendation

Feature Nginx (Open Source) Caddy Traefik
Primary Philosophy Performance, Stability, Manual Control Simplicity, Security, Automatic HTTPS Cloud-Native, Automatic Service Discovery
Automatic HTTPS No (Manual setup with Certbot) Yes (Built-in, default) Yes (Built-in)
Dynamic Configuration Clunky: Generate file + reload process Excellent: Full REST API for atomic updates Excellent: Service Discovery + API/File providers
Ease of Use Steeper learning curve Very Easy Moderate (concepts of providers, routers, etc.)
Ecosystem Huge, mature, extensive modules Growing, modern Strong in container/orchestration space
Best Fit For… High-performance static sites, well-defined infra PaaS/platforms needing a simple API, web apps Docker/Kubernetes, microservices architectures

Recommendation

For building a platform where a central control plane (Hop3) needs to programmatically add, update, and remove routes for user applications, Caddy is the ideal choice.

  • Its JSON REST API is designed precisely for this purpose. It’s simple, powerful, and allows for atomic updates to individual applications without affecting the rest of the system or requiring process reloads.
  • The automatic HTTPS is a massive operational benefit, saving you the complexity of managing SSL certificates for every application we host.

Traefik is a very close second, especially when the platform deploys applications as Docker containers. Traefik can be configured to watch the Docker socket and use labels on the containers to define their routes, which is a very elegant, hands-off approach.

Nginx (Open Source) is the least suitable for this dynamic requirement. The “generate file and reload” pattern is brittle, less efficient, and more complex to manage compared to a true API.

Page last modified: 2025-06-19 09:38:05